Do New Scientist:

The surprising truth about why adults make children believe in Santa

Children are savvier than we thought, so why do so many of them believe in Father Christmas? Answering that question reveals a lot about child psychology, and even more about adults

MIND 16 December 2020

New Scientist Default Image

The rituals we build around Santa may be more for our benefit than for our children’s

©Martin Parr/Magnum Photos

ROHAN KAPITÁNY was 7 when he started to question the existence of Santa Claus. Every Christmas, like many Australian kids, he had left out an apple and a carrot for the reindeer and a cold beer for the man himself – and every year, he found half-eaten snacks and an empty glass alongside a pile of presents the next day. But Kapitány had started having doubts. With his scepticism growing, he even hatched a plan to check his parents’ ATM receipts. “That was the beginning of the end, or the end of the beginning, of my belief in Santa,” he says.

Two decades later, Kapitány – now a psychologist at Keele University, UK – is investigating Father Christmas again. This time, he is probing the ways that children tell fact from fiction. He wants to know why some kids are more likely to believe in the supernatural than others, what makes Santa more plausible than other fictional figures and why we lie to our offspring in this way. The answers could have surprising implications for our understanding of young minds, conspiracy theorists and rituals.

As fairy-tale figures go, our modern Santa Claus is a rather recent invention. The real Saint Nicholas was born in the 3rd century AD, but it would take around 900 years for him to be recognised as a patron of children and the magical bearer of gifts. Even then, he was often portrayed as a fearsome figure. It was only in the 19th century that he took on the familiar form of a jolly old man sitting in a sleigh pulled by reindeer.

Beliefs in Santa are incredibly prevalent among children in many Western countries. One study by Jacqueline Woolley at the University of Texas at Austin (UTA) found that more than 80 per cent of 5-year-olds in the US are convinced of his existence. “The characteristics that he supposedly possesses defy everything that children know to be true about the world,” says Woolley. “People don’t live forever, they don’t have reindeer that fly, they can’t know what you want without speaking to you. Santa Claus violates all of those things, and yet children still believe in him. So you have to wonder what’s going on here.”

Some evolutionary scientists see children’s beliefs in Santa Claus as a sign of innate credulity. Children evolved to believe what their elders tell them, they argue, because it is safer than learning through trial and error when the consequences could be deadly. “It is easy to see why natural selection – the ‘survival of the fittest’ – might penalize an experimental and sceptical turn of mind and favour simple credulity in children,” wrote Richard Dawkins in his book Unweaving the Rainbow.

Yet careful experiments have shown that young children are, in fact, quite sophisticated in deciding who and what they trust. For example, Woolley and her UTA colleague Gabriel Lopez-Mobilia presented groups of 5 to 8-year-olds with fictional animals, such as the ocean-dwelling binbad. They were more likely to believe an animal existed if a zookeeper endorsed it rather than a chef, suggesting that they had already learned to take someone’s expertise seriously. Importantly, they also allowed their own knowledge to override expert endorsements. They were less likely to believe in a horse that climbs trees than one that lives in the jungle, for instance.

Children also want to see evidence before buying into more far-fetched ideas, and are sensitive to implicit clues, such as overhearing two adults talking about a fictional character in an offhand way. One October, Woolley and her colleagues told groups of 3 to 7-year-olds about the Candy Witch, who would leave a toy in return for a pile of sweet treats. Some were simply given a description of the witch. Others also overheard their parents making an apparent phone call to her, asking her to visit, and on Halloween these parents replaced some of their offspring’s sweets with toys. Children given this “evidence” of the Candy Witch’s existence were far more likely to believe in her than those who simply had to take their parents’ word for it.

“Children are, in fact, quite sophisticated in deciding who and what they trust”

This is a surprising degree of scepticism for such young minds. It also hints at the power behind the Santa myth. Parents tell detailed stories about his home at the North Pole and the elves that help him, encourage children to write letters to him and leave snacks for him and his reindeer in the evening that have disappeared by the morning. Some take their children to visit him in shopping centres or even in Lapland. In other words, parents have a variety of rituals designed to provide additional “proof” of Santa’s existence. Could these rituals be the key to his credibility?

Kapitány and his colleagues recently put this idea to the test by asking children, aged from 2 to 11, to rate the “realness” of different figures on a scale of 0 to 9. As you might hope, real people and animals – such as celebrities and dinosaurs – were at the top of the pantheon. Santa, the tooth fairy and the Easter bunny, all of whom come with associated rituals, were a close second. They were followed by ghosts and aliens, then finally by fictional characters like Princess Elsa from Frozen, which have no associated rituals. “Children are looking to see whether people’s behaviour is supportive of their beliefs,” says Kapitány. Santa seems to pass that test.

Check your conspiracy

So much for the credulous young mind. In fact, research by Woolley and her colleagues suggests that children are less likely to believe in supernatural phenomena than adults. Arguably, many of the conspiracy theories flying around the internet are less convincing than the idea of a man flying around Earth delivering presents. Unlike young children, people who buy into such ideas are forgetting to check the expertise of their sources, to use their prior knowledge and to seek other evidence to gauge the reliability of an unlikely scenario.

The big question, though, is why we go out of our way to fool kids about make-believe characters. Woolley says there is no evidence that it harms children in the long term. With Santa, it might even make sense as a way to improve their behaviour. After all, he has god-like omniscience: he knows if you’ve been bad or good and may punish or reward as appropriate. Kapitány’s surveys indicate that many parents use this threat. However, when he surveyed parents in the run-up to last Christmas, they reported that their children were just as naughty and no nicer than at any other time of year.

Given Santa’s seeming inability to keep kids in line, Kapitány suspects that these festive rituals are more about familial bonding – not to mention the sheer fun of sharing a story. Parents are often more distressed than their children when the illusion is uncovered, he says. “The magic is for the parents.”

Comentários

GOSTOPSITE33 disse…
Can I simply say what relief to get somebody that in fact knows what they're dealing with on-line. You actually know how to bring a concern to light to make it essential. Workout . should ought to see this and can see this side of your story. I cant think you're less well-known simply because you definitely hold the gift.
고스톱
TOTOSITEWEB33 disse…
A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. combat, law enforcement You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work.
스포츠토토
GUIDE1903 disse…
A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post.
성인웹툰
TOTOSAFEDB33 disse…
You completed certain reliable points there. I did a search on the subject and found nearly all persons will agree with your blog.
토토사이트
메이저토토 disse…
Thanks for such a fantastic blog. Where else could anyone get that kind of info written in such a perfect way? I have a presentation that I am presently writhing on, and I have been on the look out for such great information. 메이저토토
메이저토토 disse…
Thanks for such a fantastic blog. Where else could anyone get that kind of info written in such a perfect way? I have a presentation that I am presently writhing on, and I have been on the look out for such great information. 메이저토토
Wind disse…
Free credits that bring troops to online slot game players To be able to place bets online without having to use very high capital to play. or may not be needed at all Because we have many free credit activities. to be added to make it easier to play And if you make a deposit into the system as well You will be able to make money playing online slots much easier. because of the promotion that comes from the deposit It usually comes with a very easy turnover. pgslot
nummon disse…
The games that we are going to talk about today are quite profitable games and speaking of the basics of these games, we can say that they can be easily profitable because these games that we are going to talk about are is that the payout สล็อต
ice disse…
Slots, fun to play with deposit and withdraw money quickly, conveniently, and with free credit to new players who applied to play with us with a chance to win Unlimited big prizes, easy to play with both promotions, bonuses, many good privileges and can still play and earn real money superSlot
Dee disse…
PgSlot is an interesting game. And it's the best source of income as well. It will also be a very modern game camp. With a quick deposit and withdrawal system within 5 seconds only. Eliminate the problem of waiting for money for a long time And anyone who is looking for an online website that is the most easy to play, probably won't talk about pg Slot. There is nothing at all because it is a famous game camp. You don't have to understand much to play because it's the easiest game to play. pgslot
pgslot disse…
Seconds is a game suitable for making money bets. and suitable for playing for fun playing online slots It's playable anywhere, anytime. There is no time limit for playing, so PG SLOT can be played 24 hours a day because this game is easy to play. In terms of service, topping up or withdrawing is easy if your friends only have a few minutes a day. can join to win prizes from playing slots games Because this game does not take long to play. But it is important that the players pgslot
Ambbet Golden Pig Slot Is a very interesting game, bonuses are often broken, get money very easily and believe that the money that has been profited from playing slots games can be brought down to buy a sedan car. If interested, you can apply for membership via jackergame.com 24 hours a day บาคาร่า
The ambslot slot game is the most popular and trending game for gamblers these days. Including web slots, deposit-withdrawals, because this game camp is an easy game to play. The jackpot is often broken, easy to understand, and the game is colorful and fun to play. thrilling sound effect slotxo
llAN2 disse…
one technique that can be used to play a whole new group of players and whoever plays here It's been several months But I still don't know when and when the bonus comes (if we still can't predict when both the jackpot and the scatter symbol come), but when it comes, it's best to hurry up and get it. All new settings, bets and game rounds. By focusing on increasing the amount of bets more สล็อตออนไลน์
Anônimo disse…
I use Buffer for my social media clients. Have you heard of Grum? I use it to post to Instagram from desktop. Great suggestions here! pgslot
Thanks for sharing such a wonderful post here. I found your post perfect for my needs. Good work and keep it up. ผลบอลสด
gf223 disse…
live22, a slot game camp that has been in service for a long time which in this game camp Will be featured in the story of the classic game. with online slot games that are similar pgslot
Anônimo disse…
But the fact that ping pong It can be used in every game. It will be alternating 3 times or more. The method of observing it is not difficult. pgslot
Anônimo disse…
Spins Played by admin You can choose to use it according to your needs. free unlimited ambbet
pgslot disse…
people born on monday He is a person with a temperamental nature. Gentle, sympathetic, considerate, and also polite, making friends have to be considerate of people born on this day. pgslot
Online slots games are simple games that anyone can play. Only then you have money to bet on. amb
Anônimo disse…
New game style, easy to play, quick money. There is an easy way to break the formula. superslot เครดิตฟรี
arisa060340 disse…
pgslot Sushi Oishi Slot Game Sushi Oishi has a story that There is a sushi chef named Holden who is very famous every year. superslot
Anônimo disse…
Our Ambet Slots website is one of the giant slot game providers, PGSLOT, easy to break. superslot เครดิตฟรี
TT disse…
both through the web page directly and applications with support for up to 2 networks, including IOS and Android, etc. บาคาร่า
IIAN_VIP01 disse…
interesting thing in this game is. firing bullets The shooting technique is focus more on big fish By shooting 10 ambslot
Anônimo disse…
With a system developed by a world-class team, it is stable and secure. Welcome for you superslot เครดิตฟรี
If you haven't tried the experience yet Never played slots before, we are ready to serve the game. and introduce every detail of Online slots in wallet สล็อตออนไลน์
Anônimo disse…
Today, many different camps No matter which office it is, there are various promotions to please the bettors. superslot
Anônimo disse…
AMB Slots have produced their own unique style of slot games. The slot games of this camp will be different. AMB
Anônimo disse…
Supports Android and iOS systems that can be easily accessed. no matter where you are ambbet
gf223 disse…
Must be a member with our website first and may have to have a minimum deposit of 5 baht per day before you can join our activities. สล็อตออนไลน์
jamji disse…
that can win at slot games Which we have compiled techniques for playing online slots games. Keep it for you to try and follow. pgslot
Anônimo disse…
Free credit just apply for identity verification You can pick it up yourself on the web page. สมัครสมาชิกสล็อต pg
Anônimo disse…
Free credit 100 baht. No need to deposit. No need to share. Free credit center. in one website บาคา
Zugurwan disse…
summoning coin

The gambler should find a coin to retrieve assets to carry with him. which currently has a variety of coins to choose to worship ambbet
Anônimo disse…
It happened so quickly and so much that you can see almost everywhere pgslot
Hp disse…
Online slots, slots, direct web, slotxo, online games on mobile, deposit - withdraw, top-up with automatic system สมัครสมาชิกสล็อต pg
Hp disse…
Online slots games on mobile, top-up-withdraw via automatic system, deposit-withdraw in 5 seconds only. สมัครสมาชิกสล็อต pg
Hp disse…
For customers who are interested in the game and want the most popular online slot games. pgslot
TT disse…
Can combine fun with friends in the group. Without everyone knowing who is who and playing for real, it's really fun and safe. pgslot
Anônimo disse…
Online slots to play Must have these 5 things. Check out the best online slots websites. pgslot
Anônimo disse…
an to operate in the 1960’s. In this way, a single signal can be sent to multiple users. The old fashion way in sending mails pgslot
arisa060340 disse…
that can connect to the Internet without you having to travel far to play gambling games สล็อต
Meji disse…
villagers. and the second type is Cowboys robbing cowboys together Cass is the latter type. She set out to wander through the land of drought pgslot
mary disse…
by that web It will have a relatively high payout rate. I can assure you that You will definitely be able to make money from our website. สล็อต
วีวี่ disse…
Anyone who has come to play must come back to play again for sure. Because playing and getting real money and having to worry that สล็อตxo
Suddenly, because just registering for a new member, you will receive 100 free credits. No need to make a turn. no deposit required pgslot
Anônimo disse…
Which side has a higher score than the other side, if choosing a match with the person with the closest score of 9. pgslot
aom2536 disse…
that will change in playing games and also earning money online as well from playing online games that come in to receive in the form of live money and also a form of online gaming สล็อต
Anônimo disse…
Try spinning slots in every camp ever. because we have already selected on this website สล็อต
pacto disse…
are comfortable to play. And it is also a play that is not limitedare comfortable to play. And it is also a play that is not limited pgslot เว็บตรง
Anônimo disse…
Deposit 5 baht, get 30, can be called a hot new promotion. organized to welcome new members สล็อตxo
Anônimo disse…
SUPREME CAISHEN is a Chinese style game that provides symbols in all Chinese styles, as well as graphic images that symbolize the same. pgslot เว็บตรง
Anônimo disse…
have set out to find those treasures to bring as a reward and in addition to looking for symbols pgslot เว็บตรง
Anônimo disse…
As a result, some new players Still don't know which game to choose? breakable welcome สล็อต
Anônimo disse…
SLOTS FREE CREDITS HOT UNLIMITED BONUSES just apply
Play the game and bet it's worth it. slotxo
ANNNNN disse…
Money hunters must master this game as much as possible. Because fish shooting games are games that generate income for players as quickly as possible, pgslot
vivi disse…
ose their elasticity unless properly stretched. Yoga exercises can increase the body’s range of motion. pgslot
Anônimo disse…
Most of them for themselves will know that in fact some techniques. It's not what we've heard. Like many things ข่าวบอล
por1996 disse…
Automated security management, fast deposits and withdrawals.
has developed a system to meet the needs of customers quickly สล็อต

Postagens mais visitadas deste blog

O SEMCIÊNCIA mudou de casa

Quem é melhor? Michel Temer, Indio da Costa ou Guilherme Leal?

Qual era a montanha mais alta da Terra antes do Everest ser descoberto?